Better Commissions

A feature to help insurance agencies manage agent commissions

View prototype

Project Overview

THE PRODUCT

Better Agency’s SaaS product is a do-it-all software for independent insurance agencies.
Commissions is a feature to help insurance agencies manage agent commissions.

THE PROBLEM

  1. 87% customers were abandoning commissions right at the beginning phase.

  2. Agencies were loosing on average, +30K per month due to errors in commissions process.

  3. Every pay cycle, agency owner needed to toggle between 4 different tools to calculate total amount and pay agent.

THE AUDIENCE

Agency Owners who wants a reliable and efficient solution to pay agents a correct amount at the end of every pay cycle.

THE OUTCOME

  1. 28% churn reduction

  2. 80% increase in NPS

  3. 70% increase in feature adoption

  4. 87% reduction in commissions related complaints

  5. 80% reduction in customer training time for this feature

MY ROLE

I led the design from UX audit to launch.
I collaborated with:

  1. Project Manager

  2. UI Developer team

  3. Backend Developer team

  4. Marketing team

  5. Customer Support team

THE PROCESS

  1. User Interviews & Contextual Inquiry

  2. Existing commissions process mapping

  3. Problem Statement

  4. Competitor Studies

  5. How might we?

  6. Design Sketches

  7. Prototype

Research & Approach

User Interviews & Contextual inquiry

Why do 87% users abandon commissions even before the initial setup?

1. Commissions setup is tedious

The users required to go through hundreds of carriers providing hundreds of policies to select the ones they work with. This is all done manually. 60% users were abandoning right at this step.

2. Confusing navigation with heavy cognitive effort

3. Huge manual effort

Customers expect setup and payment to take up to 1 hour, while in reality it takes on average 4 days.

4. Missing important information

Table is missing information that would reduce commissions processing time by 70%

"We use excel to calculate commissions. It takes a full day to prep the data, 20-30 edits, and multiple back and forth between the team. All being said, it is a 2-3 day venture."
                                                                                              - Collin Smith, Agency owner

User Story

As an agency owner, I want an automated commission calculation tool to easily set up and manage commission structures for different agents and policies, so that I can automate commission calculations. The tool should reduce errors, save time on manual tasks, and ensure accurate and timely commission payments for my agents without needing to manually calculate or verify payouts.

________

Acceptance criteria

Competitor studies

Competitor studies with competitors A & B

How Might We?

1. Automization

HMW reduce the manual data entry?

2. Benefit-first

HMW guide new users to confidently pay agents in less than 1 hour?

Ideally we wanted to provide the ability to download the *IVANS data to help validate the information right in the table. But due to big technical effort, we decided to take another route with low tech effort but still benefits the user. We decided to showcase IVANS status (downloaded, pending, and manual) in the table.

_______

* IVANS - IVANS Download™ is connectivity software for automated policy-related information exchange.

Design Iterations

1. Existing table design

2. Addition of IVANS status column

3. To increase the transparency, we displayed commission plan, rate and added a column that automatically calculated the producer pay.

4 .Addition of deferred payments

Next Challenge

A user flow that would prioritize the following:

1. A producer commission setup

2. Prioritize and display all the data points to reflect accurate calculation

3. Find out an effective solution to manage unmatched policies
4. Add bonus or subtract fees

5. A place to view and download a brief report for every payment cycle

To be able reduce the time it takes to go through the commissions, I needed to design that would bring out the perception of a streamlined flow.

Image: Basic structure of commissions

For this, I first figured out the different logical entry points for users, finalized a written user flow, and eventually started working on design sketches.

Fake heading to create space

Fake heading to create space